Why I'm Done With Microsoft: A Rant
Written by Jim Squires   
Thursday, 05 July 2007 08:19
tinyx.pngWhen word finally slipped out this month that Microsoft's 360's have been running at a 30% failure rate, I was hardly surprised. Some of you may have heard me lament about this before, but I'm on my fifth console. That's fifth, with a 5. Instead of just throwing that number around like I usually do, I think it's time I give you all the hard facts.

Console #1 - March 2006. The thing was busted right out of the box. When you moved the console you could hear loose parts rattling around inside. A trip back to the store led to...

Console #2 - March 2006 (same day). Worked great until it started freezing, which took a little less than a month and led to...

Console #3 - April 2006. Perfect console. Wish I still had it. Why don't I? Had a problem where during the playback of certain DVD's the video would freeze and skip while the audio was fine. Tech support said it was the console, but...

Console #4 - June 4, 2006. Two days after this, on June 6th, Microsoft did a dashboard update that "repaired playback stutter during certain films." That's right. It wasn't my perfect but now departed console #3's fault, but their software. This in turn, stuck me with crapbox #4 which gave me my first glimpse of the dreaded red lights o'death in September. Which brings me to my current console...

Console #5 - September, 2006. For the most part (until now), a problem free console. Now that I've gotten you all up to speed, back to the story!

The wife and I sat down last night to fire up the ol' HD-DVD Player, which we had picked up just before Christmas, and were surprised to find that the HD-DVD Drive option had vanished from the dashboard. A quick call later (and by quick, I mean 40 minutes on hold) and I discover that;

A) The HD-DVD Player, a $200 item, is considered an "accessory" and as such comes with only a 90-day manufacturer's warranty, which I had clearly exceeded, and;

B) Despite the fact that I was on my fifth console, I was still only entitled to the original one year of warranty. Not one year from the time of the replacement console being sent out mind you, but one year from the date of original purchase.

Normally I try to keep my cool. I've spent a good portion of my adult life working in call centers and I know what it's like to deal with an asshole customer. I've also spent a good deal of time working in call monitoring and quality assurance, so I know an inept rep when I see one. Still, I couldn't help but blurt out "FINE! I'LL JUST SELL MY STUFF AND BUY A PS3 THEN!" When, rather than trying to make things right, she gave me the "sorry to lose your business sir" line, I hung up. Which led to me calling back. Which led to another 40 minutes on hold. Grrr....

The next representative, like the first, refused to offer me a free repair. On the bright side he did find out what the problem was. Turns out the USB port on the back of my 360 has crapped out. Why the first rep couldn't do these troubleshooting steps and save me an hour is beyond me. He bid me on my merry way with a USB cable hanging out the front of my unit, and that was that. Since that time I've done a little fiddling (ie jiggling the cables around, blowing in the port, the kind of fiddling your grandma would do with electronics) and have gotten the back port working again. For how long, who knows?

Here's the thing. I've gone through five consoles, and still been loyal enough to drop 2 hunny on the HD Player. What have I gotten for this loyalty? I'd like to say zilch, but the rep who sent out console #3 was a peach and sent me a copy of PGR3. But it's damn near close to zilch. I've just reached a point where I'm absolutely fed up. Microsoft knows that, thanks to Live, Gamerscore, and the Marketplace, they have the #1 console on the market. The problem is that, even with a 30% failure rate, they're acting like they don't need to clean up their mess. They're treating their customers like we're all in H.Y.D.R.A. -- "Cut off our heads, and two more will take our place!" It's just bullshit, and I don't think I can stand for it any longer.

So what am I going to do? That's a tough call. After all, as you can probably tell despite my negativity in this post, the 360 is my console of choice. Beyond that, I do write here -- which might be a little tough to do if I'm without the number one console on the market. So I think my plan is going to have to go as such. I'm going to keep using my slightly defective 360 (really, who's using all of their USB ports anyway?) until it craps out for good. At that time, I'm going to have to re-evaluate. As for the HD-DVD Player? That one's a little easier. I'm going to eat all the money I've thrown into it, trade it and my small but growing collection of HD-DVD's at my local trade shop, and put the money towards a Playstation 3. After all, since Blu-ray's built in at least I'll get a one year warranty. You can argue out the wazoo that it's Sony's success or Toshiba's failure that has lead to the growing dominance of BRD's, but for at least one movie-watcher it's the bullshit that Microsoft has put me through.

When my 360 finally does crap out for the fifth and final time, at least there'll be a PS3 in the house. Maybe I won't need to make that repair call after all.

EDIT: It's just been brought to my attention that both Dan and Kevin are on their second boxes, and Dan is about to make the call to move on to his third. For those keeping score, that's 3 writers, 10 consoles. Crazy. (Edit #2) -- Xav just dropped me a line to say he's on his third one and constantly gets the red ring. So that's 4 writers, 13 consoles (would be 14 if xav would get off his butt and replace that one!)


Digg! Reddit! Facebook! Technorati! StumbleUpon! ShowHype: hype it up!
Comments (19)Add Comment
...
written by Muffin Man, July 05, 2007
lol, you're all so unlcuky. I got mine in December of 2005 and is still working fine.
...
written by Xav de Matos, July 05, 2007
My original launch system worked fine and never had a problem and I only swapped it to renew the extended warranty the EB Games used to offer.

The two I've had since then have been crap.
...
written by james, July 05, 2007
My cousins and I (5 total) have all had to send it in.
My brothers box has died twice and one of my cousins is on box number 4 while the other thre are on 4 and 2 respectively.
Mine crapped out right before the elite came out
...
written by Dan Zuccarelli, July 05, 2007
I've had one lock up and die on me and now my second one is in the process of dying as well (I think it's the drive motor).

I love the games but the system is built for shit.
...
written by Dexie Oblivion, July 05, 2007
And that's the main reason I haven't bought a 360 yet.
...
written by Dr. Cossack, July 05, 2007
Somedays the news are so good that I almost consider getting a Xbox 360... But then, stuff likes this comes around and reminds me why I avoid Microsoft's consoles. Thanks! smilies/tongue.gif
...
written by Xav de Matos, July 05, 2007
It goes without saying that the system itself is fantastic with some great software.

Sadly it has some flaws.
...
written by Dexie Oblivion, July 05, 2007
Dr. Cossack: The first Xbox was built pretty solidly and didn't have these problems...it was as huge as hell, but it worked great. XP
...
written by Dan Zuccarelli, July 05, 2007
Xbox 1 was built like a tank, and never faltered once for me... the 360 on the other hand... not so much
...
written by Ken, July 05, 2007
Jimmy Jimmy Jimmy....
this is why I refuse to give Bill Gates dime one of my hard earned cash!!!
thanks, though, for going throught this crap and reporting on it so I don't have to. You are my lighthouse, man!
...
written by Grim Santo, July 05, 2007
I hsve owned two 360 a standard one (Which i give to my girl friend) and a elite. I never had problem with either. I guess I am lucky as most everybody i know has had to return theres. As for sticking with just a PS3. It would be a mistake until Nov. as there are next to no games for it. Unless you count Blurays as that is all i use it for at the moment.
...
written by Xav de Matos, July 05, 2007
I've said it once and I'll say it again.

My favourite PS3 game is the internet browser.

Really, what else is there right now?
...
written by Ben, July 05, 2007
This announcement may come too late but you might still want to check it.

http://gamerscoreblog.com/team/default.aspx

Haven't read throught it all but from what I can tell, "red ring of death" problems have their warranties extended up to 3 years.
...
written by OPT1MUSPR1ME, July 06, 2007
I had my my 360 crap out on me about a month after I bought it (Sept. 2006). Swapped it using my Best Buy extended warranty. On my 2nd now and it has been great (knock on wood). Somebody need to have a poll so we can get some real failure rate percentages.
...
written by Katana, July 06, 2007
Never had a problem with mine and I've had it since launch.

As for your HD-DVD drive, if this consoles dies and you don't get another, you don't have to throw the HD-DVD drive and movies out. You can take that drive out of it's enclosure and use it in a PC.
...
written by Brisk317, July 06, 2007
...
written by Kevin, July 06, 2007
I'm on my second, but Microsoft has just regained most of my confidence. They have announced that ALL consoles will have a 3 year warranty on Red Ring of Deaths faults (as opposed to 1 year on other faults, like the Xbox, PS3 and Wii already have). So, if you get the Red Ring of Death within 3 years of the purchase date, they'll fix it for free. Also, if you believe them, they have apparently figured out what is causing so many Red Ring of Death occurances, so perhaps we will start to see the number of faulty consoles decline rapidly.

It's a bummer about the software failures and other faults, but all I have experienced is a Red Ring of Death, so I'm happy staying with Xbox for now.
...
written by I am x-box Fan » Why I&#, November 16, 2007
[...] read more | digg story [...]
...
written by TheBBPS.com (Bits, Bytes, Pixe, October 13, 2008
[...] at some point I’ve just learned to accept this as an inevitability.  If you’ve read my rant from July 07 on the subject, you’ll know I’m now entering my sixth console.  SIXTH.  So fuck it.  I’m just [...]

Write comment

busy
 

Stalk Us

Staff

Editor-in-Chief - Daniel Zuccarelli
The Guy Behind The Guy - Daniel Lloyd
Podcast Editor - Kevin Alexander

Contributors
Marc Deangelis
Jim Squires
Ryan Hewson

The BBPS Sponsors

This is one of our favorite sports memorabilia sites on the web.

About Bloguin

Bloguin is the revolutionary blog network specifically focused on helping bloggers get the most out of their websites. We're currently working on building a large network of online communities and hope to expand our blogging coverage to include a wide range of topics.

Advertisers

The Bloguin Network allows advertisers to promote their products and services to our ever-growing number of visitors. We offer both site-specific ad placements as well as the ability to run a network-wide campaign. If you're interested in working with Bloguin to meet your advertising needs, please contact us.

Most-Wanted List

The Bloguin Network is always looking to expand. We're specifically looking for blogs in the sports, entertainment, and video games field, but are open to adding any type of quality site.. If you're a blogger and interested in joining our network, please fill out our  application form.

The Bloguin Login

The Bloguin Login gives you full access to everything our network has to offer. Your name and password will work for each and every one of our sites. Signing up is simple, and will allow you to post in all our forums, create member blogs, and access other cool features! What are you waiting for? Create an Account!